Contradiction or non-contradiction? Hegel’s dialectic between Brandom and Priest
In: Classical German Philosophy New Research Perspectives between Analytic Philosophy and Pragmatist Tradition XLI , No. 1-3 ( 2012 )
Sezione Saggi / Articles
The aim of the paper is to analyse Brandom’s account of Hegel’s conception of determinate negation and the role this structure plays in the dialectical process with respect to the problem of contradiction. After having shown both the merits and the limits of Brandom’s account, I will refer to Priest’s dialetheistic approach to contradiction as an alternative contemporary perspective from which it is possible to capture essential features of Hegel’s notion of contradiction, and I will test the equation of Hegel’s dialectic with Priest dialetheism.